Monday, August 13, 2018

#28 Woodrow Wilson: Paralysis in Mind and Body (1913-1921)



“Wilson” by A. Scott Berg 2013

Woodrow Wilson may have been our most intelligent, educated, morally driven president but his arteries hardened just a quickly as his idealism.  Both lead to a man who had amazing ideals but the inability to achieve many of them.  However, his popular image as a cold, unbending man does not at all match the driven, passionate man portrayed in this book.

Thomas Woodrow Wilson was born in Virginia in 1856 to a Presbyterian minister father and mother from a well to do Ohio family.  The family moved to several different southern cities as he was growing up, spending the majority of his years in Georgia, North Carolina and South Carolina. He was the favorite child in his family and constantly told how God had great plans for him. He was a slow learner, unable to read until age 10 due to dyslexia.  However, upon learning shorthand he was able to write and read much faster.  Using a typewriter much of his life also compensated for this issue. His father helped him compensate by emphasizing his oral skills, having him recite famous speeches over and over.


 Wilson headed to Princeton for college and just blossomed there.  He became involved in many clubs- becoming editor of the school paper and one of the best debaters on campus.  While there he developed a desire to get into politics. However, he was a bit lost after finishing his undergrad degree and went to Virginia law school for a year before passing the bar in Georgia.  His brief attempt to start a law practice was a failure and he headed back to school at Johns Hopkins to earn a doctorate in history and political science in 1886.  His incentive to earn a good living as a college teacher was driven by his desire to marry and support a family.

Ellen Axson Wilson
Woodrow met Ellen Wilson in 1883 in Georgia.  Her father was a minister who had mental problems and she was having to raise all her siblings.  Ellen was a very talented and educated artist who had sold paintings and had exhibitions in New York and Paris.  But after they married in 1885, she put all of her art ambitions aside as they had 3 daughters in the first four years of their marriage.    If you read their love letters, the physical and emotional passion and total connection of their lives was amazing.  Ellen struggled with depression off and on much of her life but usually tried to hide it from her family.  Her painting was a source of release for much of her emotional issues.  Honestly, Woodrow Wilson would never have become president without her guidance, advice and support.  Fascinating woman.
Painting by Ellen Axson Wilson
After receiving his doctorate, Wilson taught at Bryn Mawr then back to Princeton to teach history, political science, and economics. He constantly guest lectured at other colleges and civic groups, along with writing essays and books on government and history, all to bring in extra income for his growing family and to increase his exposure.  Wilson’s skills as a speaker were phenomenal.  He was constantly voted the best teacher at Princeton, getting standing ovations after his lectures. 


In 1892, Wilson was named president of Princeton University and immediately began to enhance the academic rigor, expand its program offerings, and build new facilities.  His ability to schmooze money from rich alumni and his popularity in the community helped this process.  One of the other teachers was his best friend, but when he confronted Wilson about his most drastic desired change at the college, Wilson cut him off completely, feeling betrayed and never speaking to the man again. This set a pattern with Wilson of his taking any criticism very personally from those close to him and his ability to hold a grudge for life.


 Wilson’s struggled to establish a graduate school and then in 1906 he had a stroke which left him temporarily blind in one eye.  He was diagnosed with very high blood pressure and hardening of the arteries.  This condition can be linked to his increasing emotional swings and irritability. To recover from this, he took a vacation to Bermuda where he met a married woman named Mary Peck.  While their letters reveal a passion and closeness, it is unknown if it became a physical affair.  However, it did upset Ellen and so Wilson ended it.  In later years Mary Peck was used by political opponents as a scandal.  However, Mary Peck never released her letters from him until after his death even though she was offered a huge amount of money for them by republicans.

Every college kid needs this poster size in his room.
Wilson returned to Princeton and became disenchanted with the resistance to his ideas.  His inability to compromise was becoming an issue and his desire to eliminate the socially elite clubs at Princeton caused conflict with wealthy, snooty donors.  State democratic leaders convinced him to run for governor, thinking that his political inexperience would make him a perfect puppet for the party bosses in New Jersey.  Wilson accepted the nomination but after winning he immediately cut off contact with the corrupt party bosses and instituted laws that eliminated their control in New Jersey.  His progressive changes in the state led to national exposure and after just two years as governor, he was asked to run for president.
Would have made a great campaign picture. 

The Democratic convention of 1912 was full of drama as William Jennings Bryan (a two time loser for president) and Champ Clark from Missouri were also battling for the nomination.  Bryan was never going to be selected so eventually he swung his support to Wilson. (Ellen invited Bryan over for dinner without telling her husband and got the two men to discuss their differences.  If she had not done this, who knows how history would have turned out!) On the 46th ballot, he got the Democratic nomination.

The election of 1912 was historic because the republican vote was split when Theodore Roosevelt started his own Bull Moose party and the incumbent republican president Taft also ran.  TR was a progressive with ideas very similar to Wilson, but their personalities were totally opposite.  Wilson was seen as academic and cold while TR was passionate and hot headed.  The main difference was their views on monopolies and tariffs.  Wilson felt they needed restrictions and Roosevelt was much friendlier to monopolies.  Wilson’s appeal to the common man and support by labor, women and blacks helped him squeak by and win.

During his first term in office Wilson lowered tariffs, created the Federal Reserve system, began the income tax, created child labor laws, and passed an anti-trust act.   He was totally hands off with his cabinet leaders and their departments, a move which allowed him a pretty cushy daily work schedule and time for 9 holes of golf every day.  The official presidential doctor, Dr Grayson, encouraged lots of exercise for his high blood pressure but in times of stress Wilson would get massive headaches, a sure sign of problems.


 Wilson knew nothing about foreign affairs when he came to office and stumbled in dealing with the Mexican Revolution.  William Jennings Bryan was his secretary of state and they frequently clashed on issues.  Wilson began relying on an “unofficial adviser” named Colonel House and they became very close.  As the First World War began in Europe in 1914, Wilson struggled to keep the US neutral, especially after the sinking of the Lusitania in 1915.

Wilson was also very distracted because Ellen was dying of Bright’s Disease, a kidney ailment.  After her death in August 1914, he fell into a deep depression until Dr. Grayson introduced him to a wealthy widow named Edith Galt in Feb 1915 and he fell deeply in love.  He would write her 2 or 3 love letters a day and proposed soon after they met, even though it had not been long since his wife’s death.  They tried to keep it hidden but people actually spotted them necking in the presidential car and so they finally married in a small ceremony in her house in Washington DC in December 2015.

When running for reelection in 1916, Wilson emphasized that “He Kept Us Out OF War” and won a very close race.  However, after the discovery of the Zimmerman telegram in which Germany tried to get Mexico to attack the US, Wilson knew it was time to go to war. In April 1917 congress declared war and Wilson pushed through several controversial acts to suppress opposition in the press or other groups.  This led to jailing thousands of writers, labor leaders, German immigrants and others- the worst violations of civil rights in American history.   The government also quickly seized railroads and controlled almost all factory and food production.  By 1918 the Yanks had landed in Europe and along with the British and French quickly defeated the Germans. 
Europe treated Wilson like a rock star.


Clemenceau was very stubborn
Wilson came up with “Fourteen Points” which would allow the Germans to lose with dignity and prevent future world wars by a creation of a League of Nations. The Germans surrendered with the assumption that a treaty would be based on this.   Wilson was hailed as a hero in Europe. But when Wilson went to Paris for the 1918 peace talks, he was constantly blocked by French President Georges Clemenceau, who wanted vengeance and the destruction of Germany.  Wilson had to return to Washington briefly to deal with republican opposition to his ideas and by the time he returned to Paris, his friend and adviser Colonel House had compromised on many of Wilson's ideas and the League of Nations.  Wilson was furious and struggled to win back his points from the allies, eventually only succeeding in clinging to his League idea and letting most of the other points go.   He never forgave House and soon stopped speaking to him forever.


Carefully staged pictures to hide his disability
When Wilson returned to the US to get the Treaty of Versailles ratified, the republicans had taken control of the house and senate. He was exhausted and in poor health with blinding headaches, unpredictable mood swings and an obsession about his beloved League of Nations becoming his legacy to the world.  The republicans, who felt left out of the peace talks, blocked all attempts to ratify it so Wilson decided to sell it directly to the people by doing a massive national train and speaking tour.  He was very popular at all his speeches but towards the end of the tour in Pueblo, Colorado he had a stroke.  He immediately returned to Washington where he had a massive stroke four days later in October of 1919.  His left side was paralyzed, left eye completely blind and minimal vision in his right eye even though his mind was fairly sharp apart from wild mood swings and depression.  His wife and Dr. Grayson, hid him from the world for weeks as she filtered the information and access to him.  Wilson eventually recovered enough to walk a bit with a cane and attend cabinet meetings.   For the remainder of his presidency, he was essentially a lame duck and many claim his wife Edith was actually in charge. This inability of anyone to force a president to resign for being incapacitated eventually led to the passage of the 25th Amendment to the constitution.

After the presidency, Wilson and his wife Edith bought a house in Washington DC but he lived a pretty secluded life.  He tried to practice law briefly or write a book but both were just too much physically or mentally.  He was seen each week at a local theater in Washington and gave his last brief speech in 1923 on Armistice Day.  He continued to deteriorate physically and never recovered emotionally from the loss of his League of Nations… which the US never joined.  After his death he was buried in the National Cathedral in Washington DC and his Washington home is now a museum.


History has not been kind to Woodrow Wilson.  The massive violation of civil rights during the war was pretty horrible. However, Wilson also claimed he would help blacks in order to get their votes in 1912, but he did nothing for them. In fact he tolerated segregation in his own administration and ignored Jim Crow laws. He was known to view blacks and women as intellectually inferior, making derogatory comments about both.   He offered minimal support for women’s suffrage and only finally supported it when it would obviously pass.  A sad legacy for a man who thought his ideas would end war forever.